It was a dreary Monday morning in Manhattan; the sort of rainy, dark day that makes you wonder why you were still in Manhattan when you could be…..well, anywhere else. New York is a great place to be if you have the money to enjoy it. The shows, the museums, the restaurants – all ideal for those making six figures or more. Since I was short of that number by a couple of zeroes, it was a challenge.
I walked into my waiting room and saw the usual assortment of dirty faces, dirty hands and dirty clothes, all looking up to me as if I could help. I smiled good morning as best I could and made my way to the front desk. Gloria, my actress slash receptionist, was drinking her Starbucks chocolate foam double latte and shaking her head at me.
“Oh, we’ve got a winner today,” she said under her breath. “Three missing husbands, two repossessed cars, a stolen lottery ticket and the guy in the corner claims to be the rightful owner of the missing Hilton fortune.”
“I didn’t know the Hilton fortune was missing.”
“It’s not. Which might make the case a bit harder.” Gloria sighed as she handed me their names on a scrap piece of paper. “By the way, I have an audition at three o’clock.”
“The Lion King,” she said. “If I’m lucky, I get to play a zebra.”
My mind immediately went to how a zebra would look if they had a size 42 inch chest but I shook it off and looked at the first name on the list.
“Mrs. Romano?” I called out. I watched as two women slowly made their way out of the chairs. One of them….the younger one….looked strong and stoic, in her early thirties, with dark raven hair. Very serious. One could imagine her being quite the beauty if she would only smile. The other was of similar type, dark hair and robust, but older. She looked like she’d been crying for the better part of a week. I led them back to my office, a small rectangle with yellowish wallpaper just big enough to fit me, my desk, a couple of chairs, a tall filing cabinet and a liquor closet. I gestured for them to sit down and tell me their story.
Lilly Romano was the younger one and started speaking, clearly and in an even voice. She’d met an older man and gotten married at a young age. They had three children in the span of a dozen years. Then suddenly last week in the middle of the night the father up and disappears, taking nothing but his wallet, his checkbook, not leaving a note. In her mind he was the victim of foul play; a kidnapping, or possibly worse. I had another theory. He was the latest in a long line of deadbeat dads who found the responsibilities of raising a family in the big city more work than he counted on. So he split. This is rarely what my clients wanted to hear.
“Mrs. Romano,” I began, “I will be happy to make some inquiries and look into this for you. But I feel obligated to tell you I don’t have much hope. I know it’s difficult, but I think you need to consider that your husband is not coming back and how best you can get on with your life, for the children’s sake. Now, I have some forms I can help you fill out…”
“I don’t understand,” she said. “Do you think he is dead?”
“No, I don’t think he’s dead. But I also don’t believe he is coming home.”
“You’re wrong,” the other one said sharply.
“And you are…?”
“I am Diego’s sister. He would not do that. Not to his wife, not to his children. He loved them. Let me show you pictures….”
I watched as she pulled out a small wallet sized picture book and put it on my desk. It was full of photos of the family. The children looked to be happy enough. If the pictures were current the oldest girl could not be more than twelve. The youngest around six or seven. The father looked indeed considerably older than Mrs. Romano, but still very vital for a man his age and in good health. The pictures showed a happy, content family. Having been in the business for fifteen years now, however, I knew that pictures can lie.
“Look, I know how you both feel, and I’ll be happy to make inquiries, but really….” I never got any further than that.
A tremendous roar came from my waiting room, a combination of loud yelling and somewhat hysterical crying. I quickly moved to the door and opened it. What had been a full waiting room was now occupied by only Gloria and a tall, thin, well dressed man wearing an Armani suit, a pair of Italian loafers, a gold watch worth more than my car and a huge smile. Gloria was putting on her coat and thanking him profusely.
“I’ll see you in a few hours,” she called to me as she ran out the door. “Thank you!”
“What the hell….?”
“Forgive me,” the man said. I watched in amazement as he strode past me to Lilly Romano. He whispered some sentences in her ear, handed her what looked to be money, and escorted both women past me and out the office door. Mrs. Romano looked confused. She spoke softly to her sister in law and showed her the money. They looked at the man as if he were crazy but then looked back at the money. Lilly Romano nodded, just once. He waved merrily to her and locked the door.
“That’s better,” he said.
“Who the hell are you and what do you think you’re doing? Where did Mrs. Romano go? Where did all my clients go?”
“All reasonable questions. Simply put, I told them that we needed some alone time and that they could all come back tomorrow. To make up for the inconvenience I gave them each a thousand dollars. Apparently, that was the right sum.”
The man walked into my office and sat behind my desk, making himself quite at home. He was about six foot two, early forties, premature grey hair, looked to be in excellent shape.
“Well, that’s terrific for them,” I said. “But the initial question still remains. Who the hell are you?”
“The name is Connor. Connor Phelps. Perhaps you’ve heard of me?”
“Connor Phelps, the millionaire?” I asked.
Connor shook his head good naturedly. “Jack, a little lesson in arithmetic. A million seconds is just under twelve days. A billion seconds is just over thirty-two years. I am a billionaire.”
Connor Phelps. Of course, I’d heard of him. The Phelps family was one of the most affluent and influential names in New York history over the past century. Their fortune began in plastics and manufacturing automobiles but as the years evolved so did they, always staying on the forefront of new technology. The last thing I read about them was a few months back in the Sunday section of the Times, how they were re-inventing digital technology.
Of course, now that I knew who he was, that made it even more bewildering as to what he was doing in my office.
He saw the look of confusion on my face and smiled. “Jack, relax. I’m going to tell you all about it. Have a seat. Or better yet, pour us a drink if you have some. Scotch for me, please.”
“It’s nine a.m.,” I reminded him.
“Here in New York, yes,” he said. “But if you just flew in from Switzerland, as I have, it’s just after 3 p.m. Granted, that’s still a little early, but I can take it if you can.”
I went to the liquor closet and poured us both a glass of Dewars. The last time I’d had Scotch in the morning was, well, not that long ago, sadly enough, but given the circumstances I thought it made sense. I handed him his glass. We both took a long drink.
“So, what shall it be?” Connor asked. “Your questions, or my answers?”
“My questions,” I said.
“Excellent. I do like an inquisitive man. Proceed.”
“You’re obviously not here because you need my help,” I said.
“Technically, that’s a statement, not a question, but you’re right. Thankfully, I am not currently in the position of requiring the aid of a private investigator.”
“And if you were, I doubt seriously you would choose me.”
“No offense, I hope,” he smiled.
“None at all,” I answered. “So you’re here for another reason. What is it?”
“It’s very simple. I’m dying.”
I’m not sure what I was expecting Connor Phelps to say, but it wasn’t that. He burst out laughing.
“Well, don’t look so sad,” he said. “I’m not dying anytime soon, God willing. But eventually, at some point, I am going to die.”
“Okay,” I said. “And you’re just now coming to this realization?”
He sat up. “Believe it or not, yes. You have to understand, we Phelps’ are, by and large, a shallow lot. We’ve had everything handed to us from the time we could walk, taught from early on that the only value in life was the kind you could spend. Mind you, in the grander scheme of things we’re monumentally important. We build cities, create jobs, support the arts, all that stuff. Hell, compared to others in our tax bracket we’re downright philanthropic. But we do all this from afar. We never get our hands dirty, do anything to help individuals. So there I was, sitting on a yacht in the middle of the Mediterranean, drinking a bottle of 1997 Salon Blanc de Blancs Le Mesnil-sur’Oger champagne, staring up at the stars and I suddenly had an epiphany. From out of absolutely nowhere, I realized something. Do you know what that was, Jack?”
“That some champagnes have absurdly long names?”
“I realized that I would never be remembered. That everything I was doing was eventually going to be for naught. Fifty years, a hundred years, a thousand years….what difference does it make? What difference does any of it make? Whatever we build, whatever we create, time will eventually destroy. I realize this is common knowledge to most people but for me, it sort of came as a jolt. At that moment I decided my life was going to change.”
“And somehow that led you here?”
He grinned and took another sip. “In a way, yes. I mean, what I decided was I was going to start helping people. Individual people. People with faces I could see, hands I could touch, faces I could remember. People who needed my help. I want to be a private investigator. Help those who can’t help themselves, use the resources at my disposal to touch lives. That way, when I die, perhaps I’ll have something more to remember than a couple of profit sheets.”
I took another sip of the scotch. I decided that drinking at 9 a.m. really wasn’t that much different from drinking at 9 p.m., so long as you had someone to drink with.
“Why don’t you just give them money?” I asked. “The people you want to help. That’s the traditional way it’s done, isn’t it?”
Connor sighed. “Because, as cliché as it sounds, it’s true. Money does not buy happiness.”
“I have an empty waiting room which says otherwise.”
He scoffed and tossed his hand. “That. That is temporary. A band aid, at most. They’ll be back. Take my word for it.”
“You still haven’t said why me specifically,” I pointed out.
“Well, one has to start somewhere. Why not you? Besides, your office is right around the corner from our main headquarters. One thing you should know about me, Jack. Deep down, I am a lazy man.”
“Noted. Let’s move on. Why do I need you?”
Connor looked surprised. “Because I’m enormously wealthy, of course.”
“And don’t think that’s not a huge point in your favor. But while I’m every bit as greedy as the next guy, what I don’t need is to babysit a spoiled rich kid while he pretends to be Sherlock Holmes. I’m not going to lie, I like the money aspect of this, but what else do you bring to the table?”
Connor sat for a moment, thinking. He nodded his head. “Stand up,” he said.
I stood. He rose from the chair and walked around me, inspecting me from head to toe.
“You’re thirty eight years old,” he said, finally. “You have a gym membership but you don’t use it more than twice a month. You were once married, but now you’re not. You’re not divorced, she passed away. My condolences. You have two brothers and a sister, same as I do. You have a cat. You don’t own a car, probably don’t even have a driver’s license. Live in Brooklyn, in an apartment, on an upper floor with no elevator. You have no interest in sleeping with your incredibly busty receptionist, although she certainly has a strong romantic attachment to you. But since your last affair with a receptionist ended badly, you have no intention of going through THAT again. I don’t blame you. You play chess, and you’re not bad. You like Scotch, obviously, but you prefer vodka martinis. You buy your shoes at Payless, your socks at K Mart, your pants at Jack’s, but for some reason you splurge on your shirts. The one you’re wearing was bought on sale from Italsuit, somewhere around $49, which is a great price. Have I missed anything?”
I stood there in shock. “You did not get all that just by looking at me.”
He burst out laughing. “Of course, not! I knew it all before I stepped in your office. But that’s what I bring to the table. Information. The strongest weapon in any arsenal. Access to any information at the drop of a hat. Credit card receipts, loan applications, driver’s licenses, arrest records, school transcripts…..I have a thousand employees at my disposal, from all over the world, including the smartest people on the planet. We figure out what we need, they give it to us. Immediately. Tell me another agency that can do that, at any price.”
I had to admit, Connor Phelps was a very persuasive man. He continued.
“Now, as to our financial arrangement. You, of course, will keep all the fees that come in, I will cover all expenses. I had toyed with the idea of paying you a phenomenal sum of money for the privilege of working side by side with you, but of course, I realized you would never accept it.”
“I wouldn’t?” I asked. “Are you sure? Why wouldn’t I?”
“Well, because then you would be my employee, and this isn’t about employer/employee, this is about partnership. Equals. You want to be able to tell me to go to hell if I deserve it, and you can’t very well do that if you’re on my payroll. In this capacity, you’re the master, I’m the student. But don’t worry, there will be plenty of perks that will act as compensation.”
Deep down I knew he was right.
“So where do we start?” he asked, finishing his scotch. “That woman who was just in here, she seemed like a good candidate. Attractive, even beautiful if you subtract the black outfit, but somewhat distraught. Wedding ring still on, I assume it had to do with the husband?”
“You assume correctly, except for the part about her being a good candidate,” I said, lifting her sheet. “I’ll dig around but odds are all I’ll come up with is a man who got bored with being a husband and father and left for greener pastures. It happens all the time.”
Connor picked up her small photo book and went through it, his eyes narrowing. “You’ve seen these pictures?”
“I’ve seen them.”
“The man in these photos wouldn’t leave these kids, not voluntarily.”
I shrugged. “People are not always what they seem.”
“Well, yes, I know, but look at them. He’s at least twenty years older than she is. And look at this picture on the beach. You take away the puffy eyes, the shawl, the unkempt hair, she’s a downright knock out. I could maybe see her leaving him, but I can’t see him leaving her.”
“It’s not always about looks,” I explained. “You don’t know what goes on behind closed doors.”
“I see your point,” he said. “Still, this doesn’t smell right. I’ll tell you what, let’s make this our first test case, see how we like working with each other.”
“What, you want me to drop everything I have for this?”
Connor looked out at the empty waiting room. “All tied up now, are you?”
“Hey, that’s your fault. And yes, I do have other cases, my life did not begin when Connor Phelps walked into my life.”
“Didn’t it?” he smiled. “Come on. Indulge me. Where does Mrs. Lilly Romano reside?”
“Brooklyn,” I answered. “East Flatbush, to be specific. The best way to get there is the number 2 train, and then a bus or cab.”
Connor stood and fairly sprinted towards the door. “Well, yes, we could do that, or we could simply jump in the limo parked across the street. I’ll have the driver program the address into her gps. I’ll meet you outside.”
I went to the window and looked at the long, black limousine sitting outside. I could get used to perks, I decided.
The driver turned out to be a stunning Spanish girl in her early twenties named Rosa. She was wearing a white shirt, black pants and a thin tie that shouldn’t have looked as sexy as it did. She smiled at me and opened the back door. I got in and sat across from a giant of a man with a thick neck and arms the size of small tree trunks, reading the New York Post. He nodded pleasantly at me. Connor Phelps was already working on his Iphone, typing in the information on our client.
“How ya doing?” I asked the giant as the car pulled away from Lexington Avenue.
“Could be better,” he shrugged. “Damn Giants cost me ten g’s this weekend. Can’t believe they lost to the Jaguars.”
“It’s a cruel world,” I said. He grunted and went back to his paper.
“Who is that?” I whispered to Connor.
He looked up. “Hmmm? Oh. That’s just Max. Max is my bodyguard.”
“You need a bodyguard?”
“My dear boy, I am worth more than four billion dollars. Of course, I need a bodyguard. Max comes courtesy of the CIA, for whom he performed numerous tasks in Iraq, Afghanistan and Kuwait.”
“But not Brooklyn,” I said.
Connor laughed. “Good point. Perhaps we should call for backup, Max.”
“I think we can handle it,” Max responded, turning to the sports section of the Post.
The trip to East Flatbush started slow, with traffic backed up on the FDR. Rosa was aggressive, but not reckless, changing lanes far less often than most cabbies would and never going above the speed limit. Meanwhile, Connor had his team forward us just about everything we needed to know about the missing Diego Romano.
“James Louie Peter Romano,” Connor read off. “More commonly known as Diego. Age 52. Born in Juncos, Puerto Rico. Father passed away when he was six, his mother came to New York to live with her sister shortly thereafter. Good student, but nothing spectacular. Two years at a community college. Became a mechanic. Owns a small shop now. Married Lilly Sanchez. She was 19, he was 39. They have three children. Currently residing in East Flatbush.”
He sat back and pressed a button on the left side of the seat. A bottle of vodka and two glasses came up from below. He poured one for himself and stared out the window, thinking.
“That’s it?” I said. “All the information in the world at the tip of your fingertips and that’s what you come up with? I could have gotten that with one phone call to the local police department.”
Connor smiled and took a quick drink. He lifted his Ipod again. “Diego Peter Romano, born in Cartagena, Spain, September 12th, 1961, at three twenty-two in the morning. Son of Arturo and Magdalena Romano. Social security number 149-23-2206. Blood type 0. Shoe size 11 and a half, waist 40 inches, length of trousers 42. Brown hair, hazel eyes. Arrived in New York, April 11th, 1980. Studied at New York University. Number of times hospitalized, three; once for tonsils, once for an appendectomy, once for a broken leg experienced when hiking Franconia Ridge, located in Lincoln, New Hampshire. His closest friend is Alexander Mijoto, who married and moved to Los Angeles in 1993. Favorite sports team – the Knicks. Favorite color – red. Favorite book – The Sun Also Rises, the Spanish translation. Loves boxing, especially the heavyweights. Allergic to shellfish. He has one sister, named Sarah, age 42, living a few doors down from him. The rest of the family is still in Spain. Has a tattoo on his back with the name Rosa on it, the name of his first sexual encounter. His first job was as a house painter but he had to quit because he experienced acute acrophobia. Became a mechanic on June 22nd, 1982, under the apprenticeship of one Harvey Peterson of Peterson’s Body Shop, located on 1352 Elm Street in Newark, New Jersey. That’s since been converted into a movie theater. Drinks Miller Lite as a rule, Corona on occasion, but tequila is his real beverage of choice. Owns pet snakes. Amateur magician.”
He looked up at me. “We can go on if you like.”
“No, that’s ok.”
“You see, Jack, the problem is not the accumulation of information,” Connor said. “It’s knowing what to do with it once you have it. Separating the wheat from the chaff, as it were. The first compact disc was invented in 1979 but the materials needed to create it existed long before that. It just took someone with patience to put it all together. That’s what’s needed here. Now if you don’t mind I have a great deal to go through before we speak with the family. Feel free to engage Max in a discussion on the local sports headlines, you’d be amazed as to how much knowledge he has in that area.”
I could feel Max smile behind his Post. He folded the paper and placed it beside him. “So. How about that Mets bullpen?” he asked.
It took us exactly forty three minutes to get to the Romano home in East Flatbush. It was a two story house in a row of similar two story houses, with a bit of yard up front. It was painted red and white. The door was a bright yellow and had a sign over it which read “Bienvenidos a todos los que entran.” Welcome to all who enter.
There was no room on the street to park a full size limousine, so Connor told Rosa to circle around for a bit while he, Max and I stepped out on to the curb. Connor was still studying his Iphone. Finally, he closed it and put it in his pocket. He stared at the house for a few seconds, then looked at the houses to the left and right of it. He put his foot on the grass of the front yard and pressed in slightly, leaving an indentation. He nodded.
“Well, one thing is for sure,” he said. “Diego Romano did not leave his wife and kids voluntarily.”
“How the hell do you get that?” I asked. “By putting a toe on the lawn?”
He smiled at me in that annoyingly condescending manner and gestured towards the house. We made our way to the front door while Max stayed behind. His body was still but his eyes were searching.
I knocked on the door. It was open by a dark haired woman in her mid forties. A look of hope quickly turned to one of suspicion when she saw who we were.
“Yes?” she asked sharply.
“My name is Jack Tanner,” I said. “You came to see me this morning.”
“You’re the detective person?”
“I am,” I said. “And this is my….partner….Connor Phelps.”
She opened the door to let us in. “I remember you,” she said to Connor. “You’re the crazy one with the money.”
“That’s me,” he answered pleasantly.
“I am Diego’s sister, Sarah. Lilly is upstairs, she’ll be down in a moment.”
Sarah led us into the living room. It was nicely decorated in a warm, Spanish style. It featured a burgundy rug on the floor with a comfortable sofa and several colorful chairs. There were glass cabinets filled with assorted pictures of what I presumed were generations of family. She was dressed in a dark button down blouse, a straight yellow skirt and heels. She asked us to sit on the sofa.
“You must understand this,” she said, sitting across from us. “Diego would never leave his family. He would not commit suicide, he would not cheat on his wife, he loved them all passionately.”
“When was the last time you saw your brother?” Connor asked.
“Monday,” she answered. “The day before he disappeared. I came over for dinner, as I do every Monday night.”
“How did he seem? Was he bothered by anything?”
Sarah thought for a second, and shook her head. “He was perfectly normal. We talked about the kid’s school, how their classes went. We talked about my work, and his work. We talked a little about the boxing match that night, someone from our home town would be fighting in Las Vegas for the title, so that was exciting.”
“So he never appeared agitated?” Connor asked.
Sarah sighed. “Just once. But he was not agitated, simply disappointed.”
“Why was that?”
She stood up, wringing her hands. “It has nothing to do with his disappearance. It’s a common fight we have, it’s been going on forever. He’s worried because I am not yet married. He keeps pressuring me to date one of the men who works for him, insisting I should go out to dinner with him. I finally told him that was never going to happen. He was upset but it was nothing major. He just wants me to be happy.”
“Your brother doesn’t know you’re a lesbian?” Connor asked calmly.
She stared at him in shock. Her face turned bright red and for just a second I thought she was going to throw something at us.
“Relax,” Connor said softly. “It’s none of our business. It’s also none of your brother’s business. We’re just here to gather information.”
Sarah looked quickly to make sure we were alone. “How did you know that?”
“It’s not important,” Connor replied. “But I presume Diego did not know.”
“No one knows,” Sarah said. “It is not done in our culture. You think we live in a modern age, in a modern city, but ours is still a very judgmental family. He….they would not understand. My parents would disown me.”
“Do they know about Diego’s disappearance?” I asked, eager to bypass the whole lesbian tangent.
“We finally had to tell them,” Sarah said. “It’s been almost a week now. We could not keep it secret forever.”
We heard multiple footsteps on the stairs. Three children appeared, obviously siblings. The oldest was a girl, with long dark hair down to her waist. She appeared to be around twelve. Her look was sullen and a bit defiant. Clinging to her was a boy, a few years younger. His eyes were red and swollen and he stayed very close to his sister. The youngest appeared to be about six. She had big black eyes and bright smile, obviously oblivious to what was going on around her.
“Who are you?” the eldest demanded.
“Mind your manners, Elysa.” Sarah said sharply. “This is a bad time for everyone, but that is no reason for rudeness.”
“You’re not my mother,” Elysa answered and from the tone you knew this was a conversation they’ve been having for a while. Sarah shook her head and stepped away.
“Are you the police?” the girl asked. Her brother held tightly to her hand, looking down at the floor.
“Not exactly,” I said softly. “But we’re here to help.”
“My father did not commit suicide. And he didn’t run away. I know that’s what you think, it’s what everyone thinks. That’s all they talk about in school. They leave notes on my locker. They whisper behind my back. But he didn’t. My father would never do that. He loved us.”
Tears formed in the girl’s eyes and her voice faltered. The boy sniffled. Suddenly, the six year old sprang forward and threw herself on the couch next to Connor. She smiled up at him.
“You’re nice,” she said to him. “You have a nice face.”
Connor sat back, surprised. She put her small hand on his face and stroked his chin.
“Does this have anything to do with the man and the suitcase?” she asked.
Connor’s eyes narrowed. “What man and the suitcase, sweetheart?”
“The night Daddy went away. There was a man carrying a suitcase. I saw him from my window.”
“Really?” Connor asked. “What time was this?”
“It was late. Everyone else was asleep. The moon was out. He had on a funny hat.”
“That’s enough, Maria.” Lilly Romano was standing in the doorway, wearing the same black dress she had on at the office. “These men have to talk to Mommy. Please go upstairs to your rooms until we’re finished.”
All three children turned from us and went back up the stairs. Maria stopped at the top and waved good-bye to Connor.
“My apologies, gentlemen,” Lilly Romano said, coming into the room. “Maria has told that story a half dozen times now. Sometimes the man is big, sometimes he is small, sometimes he has a hat, sometimes he doesn’t. You know how children are. Sarah, have you asked them if anyone wanted coffee or tea?”
“No,” Sarah answered. “I didn’t know how long they would be staying.”
“Please don’t trouble yourselves. We’re fine,” Connor said.
Lilly studied Connor for a few moments. Even dressed all in black, when she had her hair down and loose she was an extraordinarily attractive woman. “You’re the man in the office. The one who gave me the money.”
“Did you come to get the money back?” It wasn’t asked as an accusation, simply as a point of information. Connor smiled.
“The money is yours. At the time I needed to speak with Mr. Tanner alone. But your case intrigued me….intrigued us. We were wondering if you could tell us what happened.”
“The facts on the face of it are very simple,” Lilly began. “Last Monday night everything seemed perfectly normal. Diego kissed the children good night around ten o’clock. We sat watching television until eleven thirty. That’s when I went to bed. I woke the next morning and discovered that my husband was gone. He’d never come to bed that night. There was no note, no phone call. I was surprised, but not alarmed. I thought perhaps he fell asleep on the sofa, as he sometimes does, and then went out in the morning for some coffee. As the morning went on, however, I realized that something was wrong. I called his office, I called his parents, I called his friends. No one had heard from him. That’s when I called the police.”
“Was this your usual routine?” I asked.
“Not really,” she answered. “Usually I was the one who stayed up late while Diego went to bed around eleven. He has to be up by six. But he was taking the next day off to be at a parent’s teacher conference for Elysa.”
“Was anything else missing?”
Lilly Romano hesitated and then nodded. “An old suitcase. And some clothes.”
I glanced quickly at Connor, but not quickly enough. The wife saw it.
“I know what you suspect. What the police suspect. He took his wallet, his credit cards, some clothes. Obviously, he went off with another woman.”
Sarah Romano shook her head vigorously. “The hell with their suspicions! He would never ever do that. My brother loved his family.”
Lilly raised her hand and Sarah stopped. “Sarah is right. The man I knew would not desert us.”
I sighed. “Mrs. Romano, please don’t be offended, but I need to ask. To your knowledge, has your husband ever cheated on you?”
She shook her head. “Not once.”
“Was there any woman outside of you and your sister that he spent any time with? A neighbor, a colleague?”
“Did you ever fight? Have an argument?”
“What couple doesn’t argue?” Sarah asked from her corner.
“Yes, of course we had some disagreements,” Lilly answered. “In twelve years of marriage such things are bound to happen. But never anything violent. He never hit me.”
“Did he seem nervous about anything? Agitated? Something at work maybe?”
Lilly Romano shrugged her shoulders. “Nothing that I know of. Diego did not always discuss what happened at the office. He never wanted me or the children to worry.”
“Was there something to worry about?” Connor asked. “Your husband’s business….what was it again?”
“Diego was a mechanic. He owned a small shop a few miles from the house.”
“We were not wealthy, if that’s what you mean,” Lilly Romano said evenly. “But there was always money for food, rent and clothes. Diego never believed in wasting money on frivolous things, and so we managed to save.”
Connor nodded and wrote something on a pad. I could see it from where I was sitting. Far be it from me to question the mind of a billionaire, but it sure looked like an elaborate series of doodles. He smiled up at her.
“The day of your husband’s disappearance. Monday. Did you feel as if there was anything at all unusual about the day?”
She looked at him, confused. He tried again.
“What I mean is, sometimes people have sort of premonitions that something bad is going to happen. My mother used to swear by it. Did you feel nervous about anything? Anxious?”
She shook her head. “So far as I can remember, it was a perfectly ordinary day.”
I cleared my throat loudly. “Was your husband insured?”
“Are you referring to life insurance?” she asked.
“We both had very modest life insurance policies, less than one hundred thousand dollars. It was one of the points on which we disagreed. As you know, my husband is considerably older than me. I was concerned that if he passed unexpectedly it would be difficult for me to maintain our life style, simple as it is. Now it looks as if those concerns were valid.”
“Who is Jonathan Parker?” Connor asked from out of the blue. I noticed Sarah give a quick start.
“Jonathan is the man I was talking about,” Sarah said, coming closer to us. “The one Diego wanted me to go out with. Who told you about him?”
Lilly put her hand on her sister in law’s arm to calm her. “Jonathan works for Diego. We’ve known him for years. They’re very good friends. I am sure he has nothing to do with this.”
“Even so, we’d like to talk with him,” Connor said.
“He lives a few houses down. But you’ll have to go to him. He’s sustained some sort of back injury and has trouble getting about.”
“Is he an old man?” Connor asked.
“No, he just turned thirty-five. He and Diego play racquet ball at the gym. I believe he hurt it there.”
“I see,” Connor rose. “Well, I think we’re done here. Jack, do you have any further questions?”
I did, a lot of them, but not for Lilly Romano. I stood up and thanked the women and told them we’d be in touch.
Lilly stopped us at the door. “I have told the children that their father was on a trip. But that won’t hold them for very long. Elysa already knows the truth. Do you think I should maintain that fiction or do you believe we will see Diego again?”
Connor turned to her. “The good news is, your husband did not leave you for another woman, or commit suicide. You are right about that. Let’s see where that takes us.”
Lilly Romano stood frozen at the door, unsure as to whether or not to believe him. Connor nodded politely and we walked away.
We caught up to Max and walked a few paces from the house when I fairly exploded.
“Connor, what the hell was that?! How did you know Sarah Romano was a lesbian? Who is Jonathan Parker? Most importantly, how could you tell the woman that her husband did not have an affair when all the evidence so far points to him doing exactly that?”
“Patience, Jack,” he said. “We’ll discuss it at Il Buco’s. Max, make a reservation for two tonight at 7, please. You do like Italian, I trust? Of course, you do. Everyone likes Italian. Now give me two minutes to authorize the sale of a ship in Hong Kong and we’ll go visit Mr. Parker.”
Part of me wanted to grab the next subway out of East Flatbush and go back to my nice, cozy if undistinguished, life. Either Connor Phelps was the smartest man I ever knew or he was a raving lunatic. Or both. But there was something about his confidence, his demeanor….he seemed so damn sure of everything….I knew I had to at least see it through.
Plus I had never eaten at Il Buco’s.
We walked five houses down and knocked on Jonathan Parker’s door. I was not even going to ask Connor how he knew where Parker lived, I assumed that would be one of the things discussed over dinner. It took a long time for Parker to open the door. He was obviously in a great deal of pain, although his smile was pleasant. He asked us to come in.
“Sorry about this,” he said as he hobbled to the nearest chair. “I hurt it playing against Diego last week. It’s actually an old football injury, just flares up every now and then. The doctors say to just let it rest for a while and I should be good as new. Can I get you guys anything?”
Jonathan Parker was in his early thirties, attractive, and despite his hobbling, appeared to be in good shape. He had blonde hair and the look of someone who spent a lot of time in the sun. His house was modestly decorated compared to the Romanos, but for a bachelor it was very clean. Certainly a lot cleaner than my place.
“Mr. Parker, we won’t keep you long,” Connor said as he pulled up a chair. “My friend and I are looking into the disappearance of Diego Romano. I believe you knew him.”
“I worked for him,” Parker said. “I’ve been working for him for about six years now. But we were friends as well. We both love sports, so we saw a lot of games together. I know his wife, and his kids. We went to the park, to the zoo. They were a terrific family.”
“We heard that Mr. Romano wanted to have you date his sister. Did he ever mention that to you?”
Parker laughed and blew it off. “Oh, sure, he kept pushing and pushing it but Sarah wasn’t interested in me. Hard to believe, catch that I am, but for whatever reason she never warmed up to me. Perhaps it’s because I’m not Spanish.”
“Do you have any idea why Mr. Romano would leave his family, those whom he loved?” Connor asked.
Parker shrugged. “No idea at all. On the surface, they seemed very happy. He certainly talked about them a lot. It was all about the kids, how smart they were, bringing in their latest art work. He worked extra hours to make sure they had everything they needed. But….”
He stopped there for a moment and appeared lost in thought.
“But….?” Connor repeated.
“Look, this is just between us,” Parker said. “It’s just that every once in a while Diego hinted that things weren’t going so well between him and Lilly….in the bedroom area, if you know what I mean.”
Connor nodded. “I see.”
“Diego was older, but he was still very active. Kept himself in good shape. All the women who came to the shop flirted with him. He was like this Spanish version of Don Juan.”
“Actually, Don Juan was Spanish,” Connor remarked. “So in your mind, what do you think happened to Diego Romano?”
Parker shrugged again. “I have no idea. I never thought he was the type who would leave his wife and kids. But if you ask me if it’s possible that he hooked up with some rich gal who came to have her oil checked, I’m not going to say no. The man’s only human and some of these women who come in there are incredibly hot.”
“Other than things not being all they should be in the bedroom, did he ever mention any reason why he was unhappy in his marriage?”
“Nothing specific. I just know he had a bit of a roving eye. But hey. We all do a little, right? We wouldn’t be men otherwise.”
He laughed and Connor laughed with him, a bit too loudly, I thought. Connor stood up and shook his hand. “No, no, don’t get up. We’ll see our way out. Just one last question. Did you happen to mention to the police about Mr. Romano’s problems in the bedroom?”
“I did,” Parker said. “They said they would keep it confidential, they’d never tell Lilly. Do you think I shouldn’t have?”
“On the contrary, I always believe in being as honest as one possibly can. It’s when we try to conceal things that we get into trouble. Good day, Mr. Parker.”
We climbed back into the limousine, waiting for us outside of Parker’s house. I sat back and settled in.
“I’m waiting,” I said, pleasantly.
Connor looked up from the iphone which seemed permanently connected to his hand and stared inquisitively. “Waiting for what?” he asked.
“For you to tell me you were wrong, and I was right. Romano was a lech, with an eye for the ladies. Obviously he met one of them, they formed a relationship and, tired of working eighty hours a week under a car, he took off for greener pastures. His own child saw him leaving with a suitcase. I’m sorry your first case wasn’t a bit more unique.”
“On the contrary, I’ve found it fascinating,” Connor said. “Certainly more exhilarating than spending a day in the office. You may be right, Jack. Perhaps this is nothing more than a husband leaving his wife. As you say, it happens all the time. I have a different theory, however. With any luck, I’ll be able to confirm or dispute it by the time we have dinner tonight. Now, if you’ll excuse me I have a conference call to make with some friends in Geneva.”
I spent the ride back from East Flatbush discussing the legacies of quarterbacks Tom Brady and Peyton Manning with Max while Connor spent three hundred and fifty million dollars over the phone. The limo dropped me off at my apartment on West 48th Street. I walked up the five flights of the colorless interior and considered my position. On the one hand, I could use my already established right to tell Connor Phelps to go to hell and continue doing things the way I always had. As he said, I wasn’t on the payroll. On the other hand, doing things the way I always had led me to where I was – thirty eight years old, two hundred dollars in the checking account, nine hundred in savings. No home, no kids and, since Karen passed away, no family. A few close friends, but none whose world would disintegrate if I were gone. A borderline alcoholic. I spent far too many nights alone with the bottle and hiding in dark alleys, taking pictures of people whose only real crime was that they fell out of love with their spouses. Maybe a change would do me good. It certainly couldn’t make things any worse.
The light was blinking on my answering machine. Two calls, which was two more than I usually had at this hour. I pressed the green button.
“Jack, this is Gloria. Oh my God, who WAS that guy?? Is he married? Is he gay? Oh, god, he’s gay, isn’t he? Why are all the great ones either married or gay? You know he gave me a thousand dollars, right? A THOUSAND dollars! I want to marry him. Or sleep with him. Or both. Is he coming back? What should I wear? Maybe the green sweater that shows off the girls? What do you think? Oh, my god, is he there? He’s there, isn’t he? He’s listening to this! I am soooooooooooo embarrassed. Please say he’s not there. Or married. Or gay. CALL ME!!!”
The next message was slightly more subdued, but certainly more interesting.
“Mr. Tanner, this is Stephanie Miles of the New York Daily News. One of our employees spotted Connor Phelps going into your establishment this morning and then the two of you leaving in his car. I’d like to talk to you about your relationship with Mr. Phelps. You can call me back at…..”
What the hell had I gotten myself into?
I met Connor at Il Buco’s on Bond Street, between 2nd Avenue and the Bowery. He was sitting at the bar, talking into his phone, as usual. I didn’t see Max, although I imagined he was around. The head waiter greeted me with a smile and showed us both to a table back in the corner. The place was packed. Connor ordered us each an appetizer known as Uovo, which turned out to be a fried duck egg with truffles. It was probably the best thing I’ve ever eaten.
“You see, Jack,” he began once the wine came, “the world of criminal investigation is changing. Technology has taken over. No longer do we need to sleep in the back of cars or put glasses up against walls to know what’s going on. A person’s life can be traced almost completely without us ever having to leave the house. For example, you asked how I knew that Sarah Romano was a lesbian. Simple enough. At least three times a week she frequents a bar in the village named Henrietta Hudson, a well known lesbian hangout. She usually gets there at seven thirty, stays until nine, ten or eleven, depending on whether or not she’s caught the eye of another young lady, I presume. She also frequents a dating site entitled Planet Sappho. Her user name is Aphrodite. You see? Child’s play. Now, we have a tremendous edge over other agencies, and even the official police force. I am not any smarter than you, not any smarter than most of the people in this restaurant, but I have access to information that no one else in the world has access to. Perhaps that’s unfair, but in the end I remind myself that we’ve chosen this profession in order to do some good in the world.”
“So the ends justify the means,” I said, ignoring the fact that one of us had ‘chosen this profession’ only this morning.
“Always,” he replied. “Anyone who tells you otherwise is delusional. Now, I’ve spent the last six hours gathering information on Diego Romano. Not that I actually gather the information, of course. I ask my team the questions and the facts get collated back to me. What I’m discovering is that attacking a case is no different from orchestrating a buyout. In each instance, there are a thousand different points of information to be considered. When I purchase a business there are many things to assess other than price. How many employees? Who is their management? What’s the location? Is the company in debt? Are they in litigation? Who are the competitors? Are the competitors in debt? So on and so forth.”
The waiter came and Connor ordered us each the Anatra, a cast iron duck breast and walnuts. His ordering my food made me feel about ten years old but since he’d done so well with the appetizer I let him continue.
“In this case, we have an instance of a husband and wife. In your scenario, the husband has chosen to leave the wife for another woman. Fair enough. So who is this mystery woman?”
“Odds are she’s one of his customers.”
“Odds are. So we look back over the past six months of credit card receipts given to his place of business. Seventy eight percent of the people who bring their cars in to the shop are men, which would expect. Of the remaining, there are four single women. One is sixty two years old, one is seventeen. I believe we can eliminate them.”
“Men do run away with seventeen year olds,” I pointed out.
“Yes, in the letters of Penthouse Magazine. At any rate, the seventeen year old in question still lives with her parents, which would make an affair with a married man somewhat problematic, especially if he moved in with her.”
“And the other two?”
“Both of them are involved in long term relationships and, judging by transactions made in the past three days, both relationships are intact.”
“All right,” I said. “Maybe he went with a married woman. Unless you think married women don’t cheat.”
“Unfortunately, I know all too well that they do. In our case, however, there are problems. Seven married women brought their cars into Romano’s shop. To date, all of them are still living with their husbands. They may be adulterers, but they did not run away with Diego Romano.”
He paused for a second while our food was delivered and more wine was poured. A few people obviously recognized him for who he was but did nothing more than an occasional wave or smile.
“But there’s a bigger issue,” Connor said, once we were alone. “Let’s say you want to change your life. You’re tired of the humdrum existence, you want to disappear completely. What’s the first thing you need?”
“Money,” I said.
“Exactly. Do you know how much money Romano has used since his disappearance? None. Not one dime. Not one credit card transaction, not one debit, not one EZ pass, not one cash withdrawal.”
“He took it out before his disappearance then,” I said. “That’s what I would do.”
“That’s what I would do as well,” Connor agreed. “But a scan of his bank records over the past six months show no appreciable accumulation of funds, no secondary accounts, no savings withdrawals. To disappear and start a new life one would need thousands, even tens of thousands of dollars. But there’s no money missing.”
“Just out of curiosity, is what you’re doing even remotely legal?” I asked.
Connor brushed the question aside and continued. “There’s another thing. Let’s say you’re smitten with another woman and now you’re making plans to leave your wife and kids for her. Wouldn’t you call this other woman? At least once? Wouldn’t there be some communication between you, some record on your cell phone?”
“I presume there isn’t.”
“You presume correctly. Every call Romano made in the past two months can be accounted for. But there is something unusual. Here’s a printout of calls made the day he disappeared.”
Connor handed me a sheet detailing a list of calls for one day. There were about twenty calls, but one number which appeared more than a dozen times.
“Whose number is this?” I asked.
“Jonathan Parker,” he said.
“Well, they did work together. He might have called him about a business matter.”
Connor smiled. “He might. But that’s not a record of his phone. It’s a record of Lilly Romano’s.”
“Well said. While we were driving to East Flatbush I asked them my team to check the phone records of Diego and Lilly Romano, just for the day he left. This is what came up. Now why would Lilly Romano need to call Jonathan Parker that often?”
“I don’t know.”
“I don’t either, but I can guess. They were planning what they were going to do that night. One of them probably was having cold feet and needed to be reassured. If I had to pick, I’d say that was Jonathan Parker. Mrs. Romano seems quite sure of herself.”
“So they were having an affair.”
“Oh, no doubt in the world. Case in point. On September 23rd Jonathan Parker checks into a hotel in Atlantic City. His credit card shows he paid for two train tickets. He bought two tickets for a show. The meal he ate that night was too expensive for one, just right for two.”
“That doesn’t prove it was Lilly Romano.”
“People who are trying to hide their guilty transactions from their spouses rarely use their own credit cards and Lilly Romano didn’t. But she did use her ATM card. She withdrew twenty dollars from a machine in Atlantic City at six fourteen pm. Probably to buy cigarettes or something. That’s just one example. There are others. Mind you, even without all this I would suspect her. Remember what she told us about their relationship? She said ‘he never hit me.’”
“So who asked her? No one ever brought up the idea that Diego Romano was violent. No one except her. It’s just like Parker telling us that Romano had a roving eye. He wanted to plant the idea into our heads so we would suspect he left for another woman.”
My mind was whirling. “Ok, look. I buy the fact that Romano wasn’t having an affair but his wife was. I buy the fact that she called her lover a dozen times that day and that’s suspicious. But you still haven’t proved murder. Contrary to what you see in the movies, most people just don’t have it in them to actually kill someone.”
Connor finished his glass. Within seconds a waiter appeared from nowhere and refilled it. Connor nodded politely to him and continued when the man left.
“Jonathan Parker has a routine on Mondays,” Connor said. “He and Diego play racquet ball before work, around six am. Then Parker plays tennis for an hour that night at seven. Based on computer records he kept both appointments. Parker said he hurt his back playing racquet ball, severe enough that he has trouble moving about the house. Yet he somehow managed to play tennis that same night. Inference? He lied about his back injury or, at least, when it happened.”
“We’ll get to that. Here’s a list of items Parker purchased that evening at his local liquor store. Two bottles of red wine and a fifth of tequila. Jose Quervo. Do you want to know the last time in the past six months Jonathan Parker bought tequila? Never. He doesn’t drink it. But you know who loved tequila? Diego Romano.”
“Parker brought the tequila for Romano,” I said, trying to piece it together in my mind.
“Yes. Do you know what else he purchased that night?” Connor asked. “Pay per view of the heavyweight fight going on at eleven o’clock.”
“Romano puts the children to bed at ten. He gets a call or text on his cellphone around ten thirty telling him to come over and watch the fight. During the night Parker either drugs Romano….”
“…or maybe just gave him enough tequila to get him off his guard….”
“Right,” I agreed. “Then he kills him. Suffocates him perhaps.”
“Most likely. Depending on how incapacitated Romano is it wouldn’t be hard.”
I stabbed at my last little bit of duck, although by now I’d lost all appetite. It made sense. It all made sense. There was only one problem.
“We still can’t prove it,” I pointed out. “All this has convinced me, and perhaps could convince a jury if we were to get it that far, but without a body or any substantial physical evidence, there’s simply no way we could even arrest them.”
“Perhaps,” Connor mused. “Perhaps not. There are two likely possibilities for what happened to Diego Romano’s body once he was murdered. The first, more probable one is that he was loaded into the back seat of a car, driven somewhere out of sight, and buried. If that’s the case, then it could be months, even years before we find him.”
“And the second?”
“The second is, he’s still in Parker’s house.”
I shook my head. “After a week? Impossible. Even your garden variety criminal would know you’d have to get rid of the body sooner rather than later.”
“Yes,” Connor said. “Unless something unexpected happened.”
“Such as you threw out your back. Diego Romano was a big man, weighed over two hundred and forty pounds. Here’s a possible scenario. Parker keeps serving Romano tequila, getting the man drunk. When he thinks the opportunity is right, he kills him. But then he has to dump the body. Now he’s all alone and Romano is a dead weight. He lifts him and something happens. His back goes out. So what happens?”
“He has to change his plans.”
“Exactly. He drags the body to wherever he can hide him. Probably the basement. Because of his injury he has no chance to get rid of it. He either cuts it up, which is harder than people think, or more likely he covers it with something until such time as the two of them can dispose of it safely.”
“That’s taking quite a chance,” I said.
“Well, what choice did they have? Remember, we’re not dealing with master criminals here, we’re talking about two people who probably have never done anything illegal before in their lives. Considering that, they’ve done well to cover their bases so far.”
“But why come to me in the first place? Surely they would want a minimum of people looking into this.”
“I imagine it wasn’t Lilly’s idea,” Connor said. “Sounds more like Sarah’s. She knew her brother wouldn’t run away or commit suicide, although I doubt she had any idea as to what really was going on between Parker and Mrs. Romano. She’s the one who pushed Lilly into coming to see you.”
“One thing I still don’t get. The little girl saw her father leaving the house.”
“No, she saw someone leaving the house. With a funny hat. Who wears funny hats?”
“Women wear funny hats,” I said.
“My guess is Lilly Romano took the suitcase and discarded it somehow. Perhaps tossed it in a nearby trash container.”
I glanced at the clock on the wall. We’d been sitting there for more than two hours, although it seemed as if it were only minutes.
“So what do we do now?” I asked. “No matter how much evidence we think we have, it’s all circumstantial and to be honest, most of it is downright illegal.”
“Yes, that is the one sticking point to this entire process,” Connor mused as he finished off the bottle. “Pretty much everything we do is against the law, at least technically. We have to find some other way to convince people that what happened actually happened.”
I thought for a few seconds. “What would be the easiest solution?” I asked.
Connor laughed. “The easiest solution would be for one of them to confess.”
“Yeah. That’s what I was thinking, too.”
By the time Connor paid the check and got the car around to pick us up it was just after ten o’clock. Traffic was light and Rosa made the trip to East Flatbush in a little over a half hour. For once, Max and I didn’t talk sports. He sat there quietly. He could sense something was going down.
I knocked on Jonathan Parker’s door. Three knocks. Sharp and with purpose. Connor stood next to me, watching.
Parker opened the door. He seemed genuinely surprised to see us. “What is it?” he asked, nervously.
“Where’s the body, Parker?” I asked in the most menacing voice I knew.
His face turned white. “What….I don’t know what you’re talking about….”
“It’s over. It’s all over. Lilly turned you in.”
“You’re lying. I don’t know what you’re talking about.” He moved back in the house and searched for his phone.
“We know all about it,” I said as we stepped inside. “Lilly told us about you two, the trips to Atlantic City and Philadelphia. We know everything that happened the night Diego Romano died. We know about the tequila. The prizefight. How you called him and invited him over. How you got him drunk. How she got rid of the suitcase. How you hurt your back trying to dispose of the body. We know everything. Lilly says she called you a dozen times that day begging you not to do it, but you were too far gone, you wouldn’t listen.”
“That’s a lie!” he yelled. “That’s not how it happened! I was the one calling her! I told her I didn’t want to do it, that there had to be another way. She refused to listen. She said it was either this or she would leave me.”
Parker knelt down on the floor and started sobbing uncontrollably. The tears were streaming down his face. Connor leaned close and whispered in my ear.
“In a way, he’s probably relieved to get it over with. My guess is he’s been having nightmares ever since it happened. Doesn’t have the stomach for it. She definitely was the brains behind this.”
I knelt down next to Parker and spoke softly. “What did you do with the body, Jonathan?”
He didn’t stop crying but his arm went straight out. “In the basement. Under a fishing tarp. I couldn’t move him by myself so I just covered him up until I was better.”
I stood up. I started pulling out my cellphone but Connor stopped me. “Let Max and I get out of here first. This is your case. I don’t need the publicity and you don’t need me to share it. That would turn this place into a circus. We’ll meet again tomorrow morning at your office.”
“Ok. And do what?”
“First things first. Let’s start looking for a new office.”
Connor turned and left the house. I watched him get into the limousine and saw it drive away. I wondered if he realized how it wasn’t over. That for every action there was an equal and opposite reaction. Jonathan Parker and Lilly Roman would go to jail, might even be put to death for what they did, and in many ways that was right. Meanwhile, thanks to us, three small children would now go through life knowing their mother murdered their father. What consequence would that have on the rest of their lives? I wasn’t sure but I imagined something like that would bother Connor Phelps. I knew it sure as hell bothered me.
I stepped away from Jonathan Parker and called the cops.
Tony Sportiello is an award winning playwright and author. His work has been presented all over the world, including New York, Los Angeles, London, China, Russia and Finland. He is the producer of four Off Broadway shows and has two scripts in the Major League Baseball Hall of Fame in Cooperstown. He lives in New York and is married to actress Kelli Maguire. He is the proud father of Antonia Jacqueline.